COP31: Developing countries accuse rich nations of negotiating in bad faith on climate finance

Developing countries say developed nations are using COP31 negotiations to shift attention away from their legal climate finance obligations towards voluntary contributions

 

By Bhasker Tripathi18 Nov. 2026
COP31: Developing countries accuse rich nations of negotiating in bad faith on climate finance

Visual Credits: Arkatapa Basu


Developing country representatives have accused developed nations of trying to weaken their climate finance obligations under the Paris Agreement, saying discussions at COP31 are moving away from the responsibility to provide financial support towards a broader system of voluntary contributions.

Three developing country observers, who spoke to CarbonCopy on condition of anonymity, described growing frustration over the Climate Finance Work Programme (CFWP), which was established at COP30 to discuss the implementation of Article 9 of the Paris Agreement.

At the centre of the dispute is Article 9.1, which says developed countries “shall” provide financial resources to assist developing countries with climate action. Developing countries have argued that the programme should focus on how rich nations will meet this obligation, including through predictable public finance. Developed countries have pushed for a broader discussion covering other sources of finance, including private capital and voluntary contributions.

One observer following the negotiations said discussions had reached a point where the G77 and China, the main negotiating bloc of developing countries, had to break away for internal consultations.

“We came today to engage. We have stated our priorities, but our partners (developed nations) are engaging in bad faith. We cannot go further without consultations with our delegation heads,” a representative speaking on behalf of the group told the room after the huddle, the delegate recounted.

Another developing country representative said developed countries had repeatedly sought to remove references to finance and support from negotiating text.

“In the rooms I’ve been following, whenever the text mentions finance or support, developed countries want that language taken out. Developing countries have been consistently calling for the legal financial obligations from developed to developing countries. It’s almost as if developed countries are saying, ‘Do it yourself. Take more climate action without finance, without technology transfer and without capacity-building support,’” the representative said.

The disagreement has also sharpened over the interpretation of Article 9.2, which encourages other countries to provide climate finance voluntarily. During the CFWP discussions, Switzerland proposed giving voluntary contributions under this provision a more prominent role through a workstream on broadening the contributor base. The proposal received support from several developed countries, including the European Union, the United Kingdom, New Zealand, Japan, Norway and Canada, according to a developing country observer familiar with the discussions.

A third source said this approach risked shifting attention away from the obligations of developed countries.

“Instead of focusing on how developed countries will meet their legal obligation to provide climate finance under Article 9.1, they’re invoking a voluntary provision, Article 9.2, to shift that responsibility on to developing countries. In effect asking developing countries to fend for themselves,” the observer said.

The disagreement reflects a wider divide over climate finance that has persisted through successive UN climate conferences. At COP29 in Baku, countries agreed that developed nations would take the lead in providing at least $300 billion annually by 2035, while all actors were called on to work towards scaling up finance from all sources to at least $1.3 trillion a year.

Developing countries have maintained that the larger mobilisation figure cannot replace the obligation to provide public finance under Article 9.1. They have also questioned the quality and accessibility of available finance, particularly the reliance on loans and private investment for adaptation, where projects often do not offer commercial returns.

At COP30, countries established the two-year Climate Finance Work Programme to discuss the implementation of Article 9. But the negotiations at COP31 suggest that the basic disagreement remains unresolved: whether the process will address how developed countries meet their existing obligations, or widen the focus to include contributions from a broader group of countries and sources.

For developing countries, the distinction is not merely procedural. They argue that voluntary contributions cannot replace the financial responsibility that developed countries accepted under the Paris Agreement, based on their greater historical contribution to climate change.

Share

LinkedInXFacebook

About the Author

Bhasker Tripathi

Bhasker Tripathi is the Editorial Lead at CarbonCopy, working to expand how the platform helps people understand India’s climate and energy transition. He brings 15 years of experience working on climate, energy, environment and the political economy of the transition, across reporting, research, analysis, and digital storytelling.
See Author's Posts