Everyday Energy Transition: The Limits of Big Infrastructure
India's energy transition is focused on big projects and targets, while high costs and weak institutions keep small businesses and rural consumers from benefiting.
Visual Credits: Arkatapa Basu
Governments love big infrastructure projects. A big project brings many things: jobs, contracts, domestic procurement, political visibility, perceptions of modernity, opportunities for profit, and much more. Whether it is highways, metros, ports, or power plants, the last few decades have seen an explosion of infra projects in India. Yet, serious questions are emerging about whether the majority of the benefits of these big infrastructure projects are actually trickling down to citizens.
Infrastructure projects do not create long-term economic growth automatically; only the well-planned ones, which control costs, plan the surrounding environment, and respond to genuine social needs. While project selection is a necessarily risky process, there is an increasing sense that big infrastructure projects are benefiting large corporations more than citizens.
Bent Flyvbjerg, arguably the foremost global scholar on megaprojects and risk, has formulated an Iron Law of Megaprojects, which concisely states that large-scale projects are consistently “Over budget, over time, under benefits, over and over again.” This phenomenon occurs globally with a range of project types: metros, high-speed rail, underground tunnels, and even the Olympic Games, to name a few. The common thread among them is that it is frequently public money (fiscal from budgets or deposits from the banking system) that is wasted on these underperforming megaprojects. India’s non-performing assets crisis over the last decade is a good example. Among Flyvbjerg’s many suggestions is to make more modular, smaller, replicable projects with tightly calibrated cost estimates rather than huge, unique megaprojects, which inevitably become sites of rent-seeking behaviour.
Flyvbjerg’s ideas deserve to be kept in mind when thinking about India’s energy transition. Much of India’s energy transition in the last decade and a half has been driven by targets and top-down management. More panels, more inter-state transmission, more hydrogen, and more batteries. This by itself is not necessarily a bad thing, but India’s energy policy in the last few decades has often ignored the small and local in favour of the large and national.
The emancipatory potential of renewable energy, as demonstrated globally, is in its ability to unmoor decentralized populations from the fossilized inertia of a centralized grid. Most countries were locked into such grids in the half-century of power sector growth after World War II. In a relatively high insolation country like India, generating power locally for households, small businesses, and farmers could have undone decades of poor rural energy provision. Instead, India’s solar push in the last decade has largely focused on hulking centralised solar megaparks. These projects are not unimportant, but the fiscal, policy and commercial interest in these megaprojects is almost an order of magnitude larger than decentralized projects. Only recently has national policy begun to refocus on projects at the local feeder level with priorities around rooftop solar, solar irrigation, and household electrification.
Organisations like SELCO Foundation have been working for decades on trying to create renewable energy-linked business models for farmers and agrarian entrepreneurs. It is efforts like these that need to be taken more seriously. Instead of large banks lending to large power companies, which prefer to sell large amounts of power to large consumers (frequently industrial consumers, or perhaps even worse, data centres), there needs to be a change in mindset if India’s energy transition is going to be truly inclusive.
One obstacle preventing this from happening is the fact that our banks have forgotten (perhaps wilfully) how to lend to small businesses. In their haste to make big-ticket loans, NBFCs and other institutions have had to fill the gaps in MSME financing. This intermediation gets costed into loans through higher interest and ultimately our small businesses face much higher costs for solar power systems. Frequently, the economics does not make sense without large state subsidies.
What makes this worse is that the distribution of solar panel quality is not uniform for all buyers. Smaller customers in rural areas often get stuck with the worst quality panels, and only realize this after a few years when panels deteriorate and produce less power than expected. With little recourse available and low supplier accountability, many MSMEs have burned their hands on buying solar power systems and given up on building these systems for themselves.
Depending on the state, sometimes discoms don’t even know how to differentiate MSME consumers from other low-tension power consumers. In theory, there are many national and state policies which are supposed to be able to target MSMEs better; the Udyam portal is a good example of this in practice. Urban discoms have received considerable investments, are frequently private and on average are better managed. But the majority of rural discoms in India are still state-owned, underinvested, and are often more concerned with procurement, tendering, and load balancing than on serving small consumers.
Consequently, an MSME sector that could employ as many as 200 million people in our country has struggled to participate in the energy transition because of higher interest rates, poor panel quality, and relative institutional apathy, not just from some discoms, but also from the banking sector more broadly. Clearly, money needs to be reallocated somewhere.
As our national discourse starts putting increasing emphasis on job creation, economist EF Schumacher’s ideas around appropriate technologies become more relevant. Schumacher, best known for his book Small is Beautiful, defined appropriate technologies as those which were people-centred, decentralized, resource efficient, labour (not capital) intensive, and at intermediate costs. However, most of the headlines we seem to be getting these days are on record-breaking investment numbers, revolutionary tender designs, progress towards national targets, and ground-breaking pilot plants. The language of India’s energy transition today seems to have moved away from inclusive development, towards self-congratulatory, target-driven bytes generated by myopic financiers and engineers.
At COP31, India is expectedly clamouring for more international climate finance. Who knows when that will materialize. Perhaps instead it needs to take a look inwards and convince its own financial institutions that the everyday energy transition with smaller consumers is just as important as the national targets we keep touting on global fora.
[Edit: Bhasker Tripathi, Production: Arkatapa Basu]